Skip to main content

Table 1 Studies of comparison between APD and CAPD for life survival and/or technical survival

From: Which clinical conditions are most suitable for induction of automated peritoneal dialysis?

Study (published year) [reference] Study design Setting countries Data source N (CAPD, APD) Duration of observation Results
de Fijter CW et al. (1994) [15] Prospective randomized study Netherland 1988–1991) Single center 82 (41, 41) 24 months Ns.
Guo A et al. (2003) [85] Retrospective cohort study USA (1999, 2000, 2001) Multicenter >30000 (N/A) N/A APD is better within 1 year after PD induction
Badve SV et al. (2008) [86] National registry Australia, New Zealand (1999–2004) Multicenter (ANZDATA) 4128 (2393, 1735) 5 years Ns.
Liao CT et al. (2008) [87] Retrospective observational study Taiwan (1996–2005) Single center 270 (188, 82) 6 months Ns.
Sanchez et al. (2008) [8] Retrospective cohort study Mexico (2003–2005) Single center 237 (139, 98) 2 years APD is better
Mehrota R et al. (2009) [88] National registry USA (1996–2004) Multicenter (USRDS) 66381 (42942, 23439) 2~10 years Ns.
Michels WM, et al. (2009) [89] Retrospective cohort study Netherland (1997–2006) Multicenter (NECOSAD) 649 (562, 87) 5 years Ns.
Johnson DW et al. (2010) [13] National registry Australia, New Zealand Multicenter (ANZDATA) 628 (486, 142) in H category 3 months to 10 years Ns. Fatal risk was decreased in H Category
Balasubramanian G et al. (2011) [11] Retrospective observational study UK (2003–2008) Single center 372 (178, 194) 5 years APD was better for survival
Conssen TT et al. (2011) [90] Retrospective observational study USA (2001–2008) Multicenter 620 (179, 441) 3 month–7 years APD was better
Sun CY et al. (2010) [91] Retrospective observational study Taiwan (1997–2008) Single center 282 (121, 161) 3 months–10 years APD was better
Kwan BC et al. (2013) [10] Retrospective observational study Hong Kong (1995–2011) Multicenter 270 (180, 90) 9.5 months–46.5 months Ns.
Beduschi GC et al. (2015) [12] Prospective cohort study Brazil (2004–2011) Multicenter 2890 (1445, 1445) 5 years Life survival of APD was better than that of CAPD. Ns. for technical survival
Mizuno M et al. (2016) [35] Retrospective cohort study Japan (2010–2012) Multicenter 200 (119, 81) 3 years Ns.
  1. Ref. Bieber SD et al. [7]
  2. Ns. significant differences between CAPD and CAD, N/A not available in the text, ANZDATA Australia and New Zealand Dialysis and Transplant, NECOSAD Netherlands Cooperative Study on the Adequacy of Dialysis, USRDA US Renal Data System