Table 2 Comparison between APD and CAPD for preservation of residual renal function
From: Which clinical conditions are most suitable for induction of automated peritoneal dialysis?
Study (published year) | Study design | Setting countries | Data source | N (CAPD, APD) | Duration of observation | Results |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
de Fijter CW et al. (1994) [15] | Prospective Randomized study | Netherlands (1988–1991) | Single | 81 (41, 41) | 24 months | Ns. |
Hiroshige K et al. (1996) [22] | Prospective cohort study | Japan (1992–1994) | Single center | 18 (5, 13) | 6 months | CAPD was better |
Bro S et al. (1999) [16] | Prospective randomized study | Denmark (1995–1999) | Multicenter | 34 (17, 17) | 6 months | Ns. |
Hufnagel G et al. (1999) [92] | Prospective cohort study | France (1995–1997) | Single center | 36 (18, 18) | 12 months | CAPD was better |
Galler P et al. (2000) [93] | Prospective cohort study | Spain (N/A) | Single center | 20 (11, 9) | 12 months | Ns. |
Hamada C et al. (2000) [94] | Prospective cohort study | Japan (N/A) | Single | 34 (17, 17) | 24 months | Ns. (but decrease of urinary volume was faster in CAPD) |
Moist LM et al. (2000) [95] | National Registry data | USA (1997) | USRDS dialysis morbidity and mortality | 1032 (722, 310) | 8–18 months | Ns. |
Singhal MK et al. (2000) [96] | Prospective cohort study | Canada (1994–1997) | Single center | 242 (211, 31) | 27 ± 14 months | Ns. |
Holley JL et al. (2001) [97] | Retrospective database | USA (1991–2000) | N/A | 184 (70, 114) | <9 months | Ns. |
Hidaka H et al. (2003) [98] | Prospective cohort study | Japan (1995–2001) | Single center | 34 (27, 7) | 12~42 months | CAPD was better |
Johnson DW et al. (2003) [99] | Prospective cohort study | Australia (1995–2001) | Single center | 146 (134, 12) | 21 ± 15 months | Ns. |
Rodriguez-Carmona A et al. (2004) [100] | Prospective observational study | Spain (1995–2001) | Single center | 104 (53, 51) | 12–24 months | CAPD was better |
Balasubramanian et al. (2011) [11] | Retrospective observational study | UK (2003–2008) | Single center | 277 (130, 147) | 5 years | Ns. |
Cnossen TT et al. (2011) [90] | Retrospective observational study | UK (2001–2008) | Multicenter | 620 (179, 441) | 450 days | Ns. |
Michael WM et al. (2011) [101] | Prospective cohort study | Netherlands (1997–2006) | Multicenter (NECOSAD) | 583 (505, 78) | 3 months–3 years | Ns. |
Roszkowska-Blaim M et al. (2012) [80] | Retrospective observational study | Poland (1992–2009) | Multicenter | 101 children (44, 57) | 36 months | CAPD was better |
Pérez Fontán M et al. (2015) [32] | Retrospective observational study | Spain (2000–2010) | Multicenter | 493 (365, 125) | 6–24 months | CAPD was better when APD was introduced during induction period of PD |