Table 3 Comparison for effects on incidence of PD-related peritonitis between APD and CAPD
From: Which clinical conditions are most suitable for induction of automated peritoneal dialysis?
Study (published year) | Study design | Setting countries | Data source | N (CAPD,APD) | Duration of observation | Results |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Alliapoulos JC et al. (1984) [102] | Cross-sectional study | USA (N/A) | Single center | 10 pediatric patients and subsequently CCPD. | 15.0 ± 2.8 months for CAPD vs. 9.3 ± 3.2 months | Ns. |
de Fijter CW et al. (1994) [15] | Prospective randomized study | Netherlands (1988–1991) | Single center | 82 (41, 41) | 24 months | APD was better |
Bro S et al. (1999) [16] | Prospective randomized study | Denmark (1995–1999) | Multicenter | 34 (17, 17) | 6 months | 2 cases for CAPD, 1 case for APD |
RodrÃguez-Carmona A et al. (1999) [103] | Prospective nonrandomized study | Spain (1989–1998) | Single center | 328 (213, 115) | 3 months–10 years | APD was better |
Yishak A et al. (2001) [104] | Prospective observational study | USA (1990–2000) | Multicenter | 583 (384, 199) | N/A | Ns. |
Oo TN et al. (2005) [105] | National registry data | US (1994–1997) | Multicenter | 11,975 (9190, 2785) | 6 months–2 years | APD was better |
Davenport A. (2009) [106] | Observational cross-sectional study | UK (2002–2003) | Multicenter | 863 (538, 325) at the end of 2002, (635, 445) at the end of 2003 | 2 years | APD was better |
Nessim SJ et al. (2009) [107] | Prospective cohort study | Canada (1996–2005) | Multicenter | 3180 (N/A) | N/A | Ns. |
Balasubramanian G et al. (2011) [11] | Retrospective observational study | UK (2003–2008) | Single center | 372 (178–194) | 5 years | APD was better |
Rüger W et al. (2011) [36] | Retrospective observational study | Netherlands (1993–2007) | Single center | 205 (112, 93) | 14 years | Ns. |
Mizuno M et al. (2011) [108] | Retrospective observational study | Japan (2005–2007) | Multicenter | 561 (N/A) | N/A | Ns. |
Lee OK et al. (2013) [79] | Retrospective observational study | Korea (1986–2011) | Single center | 57 (51, 6), less than 18 years old | 6 months–240 months | APD was better in childhood |
Kwan BC et al. (2013) [10] | Retrospectiv observational study | Hong Kong (1995–2011) | Multicenter | 270 (180, 90) | 9.5 months–46.5 months | APD was better for induction period of PD |
Nishina M et al. (2013) [109] | Retrospective cohort study | Japan (2001–2011) | Single center | 192 (156, 36) | 10 years | Ns. |
Lan PG et al. (2014) [34] | Prospective observational study | Australia and New Zealand (2003–2011) | Multicenter (ANZDATA) | 6959 (2761, 4198) | Mean 1.9 years | Ns. |
Beduschi GC et al. (2015) [12] | Prospective cohort study | Brazil (2004–2011) | Multicenter | 2890 (1445, 1445) | 5 years | Ns. for time to first episode of peritonitis |
Mizuno M et al. (2016) [35] | Retrospective observational study | Japan (2010–2012) | Multicenter | 200 (119, 81) | 3 years | Ns. |